fayer: (Default)

the book is called PRIESTS OF MARS

Okay I think I can give a summary because the basic concept is pretty simple. There's this region of space called the Halo Scar, and a bunch of freaky stuff happens in it. Space beyond the Scar has never been charted. One fleet of Adeptus Mechanicus tried to traverse it thousands of years ago and never came back. But--wonder of wonders--a rogue trading group managed to pick up an ancient signal from that fleet.  The Adeptus Mechanicus view this as a sign from their god, the Omnissiah, that the time is ripe to try and cross over into that unknown territory again. Knowing the journey will be risky, they set out in a powerful and ancient ship, the Speranza, along with the rogue traders, military, elite guards, and god-mechs. 


THE CAST - groups 

Adeptus Mechanicus: Think Vulcans on steroids. Their physical bodies are highly augmented, if not completely artificial. They live thousands of years. They communicate amongst themselves in "blurts of binary," as they believe it to be more accurate and concise than language spoken with their "flesh voice." 

    Main characters: Lexell Kotov (expedition leader)

Rogue traders: I don't think this concept needs explanation.

    Main characters: Roboute Surcouf (captain)

Black Templars: A crusading chapter of the Space Marines. Elite warriors who focus on success and domination in battle. 

The Cadian 71st: A regiment of the Imperial Guard. Soldiers, but not as specialized as the Templars. 

The Mechs: They have a name I always forget. They're worshipped as gods. One pilot lives inside the mech basically, and then has two "handlers." Also "lives" is a bit of an exaggeration. Their torsos and arms are cut and replaced with links to the mech, and their eyes are sutured shut so they can only see through their connection with their mech. 

    Main characters: Princeps Arlo Luth (mech leader)

Eldar: These aliens that have some vendetta against the cast. 

 


Okay first off I just have to get the ridiculous stuff out of the way. Here it is, in unorganized bullet points: 

  • The term "flesh voice" for IRL human voice. I had to laugh. Upon more consideration, though, I'm not sure what else I would term it...

  • This line: "He didn't even know why the sight of Ismael reduced to a lobotomized cyborg slave should upset him so deeply."

  • The dynamic of the god-mechs. Listen. They're GOD-MECHS. People worship them! They can level cities with their weapons! 

    • This is how Princeps Arlo Luth is introduced: "The deck priests were his support crew and his worshippers, devotees come to welcome a living embodiment of their god... Luth knew from bitter experience how easy it was to forget that these scurrying creatures could hurt him...The embarkation deck was a titanic space, as befitted the god-machines of Legio Sirius, honoured engines...."

    • Pages of this buildup, framing them as super-powerful, nigh-omnipotent creatures. 

    • And then.

    • "Behind him walked the rest of his pack..."

    • Oh no. 

    • Can it be? 

    • Luth felt [the other mech's] approach....a declaration of its desire to lead the pack. Luth twisted in his suspension tank, baring his engine's teeth and raising its hackles.

    • Luth speaks: "When the pack hunts, a strong alpha is its heart and soul...I am still stronger than Moonsorrow and he knows it."

    • That's right. The god-mechs are an A/B/O polycule. 

  • The author's tendency to compare a new object to an unfamiliar in-universe object. This happened several times, and always went something like "The synth-biotic haptic drive was about as intelligent as a forge world Squeasel, but twice as fast." Sometimes there was already enough context to understand what the object was, which rendered the comparison even more useless.

  • There was a surprising amount of lubrication, always played straight.....for example, "His exposed flesh was wet with chemical unguents and hot oil lubricants." Sexy!


Next: the good stuff. I don't think anyone is expecting peak literature from a franchised novel, but Priests of Mars had some bits I genuinely enjoyed. I'm not going to spend too much time on "bad" aspects (besides the ridiculous ones), because they're somewhat taken for granted, but I was surprised to have liked as much as I did. 


Most of this is stuff that I personally liked, but in the last section I dive into a bigger "craft" decision and what I think made it work. 


Language 

I believe this is common to the whole 40k universe and not just Priests of Mars,  but I love mashups of English words to make new phrases that look familiar enough a new reader can glean their connotations without having to first learn the context of the world. This can also be achieved by using uncommon English words in specific ways. Stuff like Omnissiah, Reclusiarch, Princeps, even Noosphere. I think "flesh voice" was an attempt at this that failed just because of the relative abundance of the word "flesh" in the English language, and that it's been tarnished by overusage in edgier media. Caves of Qud and Homestuck are also good at this, if you're a fan and are looking for more. 


Machine Spirits

Haha the Adeptus Mechanicus have a real deus ex machina situation going on here, don't they?!?! Basically, each mechanical object in this world has a spirit that can be supplicated by hymns, binary chants, etcetera. People will make the "sign of the cog" in danger. I thought the computerized Catholicism aesthetic was great and literature needs more of it. The distinction the Mechanicus make between "spirits of machines" (good) and "sentient machines" (heretical) was a little fuzzy to me as a first-time reader, but I was willing to go along with it.


Stuff past this has spoilers, so if you want to avoid them read the book first. 


Galatea

I love Galatea. A tank-sized sentient AI who offers wandering tech-priests knowledge beyond imagining by joining it in blissful union? Come on. Perfect. 



Scale (the last section...for now!) 

Priests of Mars starts out with a HUGE cast of the brightest minds in the Imperium-- Commander Lexell Kotov on his ship Speranza that's half the size of a planet, assisted by a whole bunch of tech-priests and tech-mages to assist him in its daily workings, the Black Templars, the Cadian regiment, and the god-mechs, not to mention the Speranza itself. And it's just one ship in a whole fleet! When you've got all this firepower on your side, it's difficult to establish stakes, or make the reader actually concerned for the fate of the protagonists. But I gotta admit, by the end, I had begun to feel it. 


The first way stakes are established is by using the characters' power against them. The first major issue the fleet runs into is when a god-mech pilot has a nightmare/flashback inside of his mech. He believes he's reliving a previous battle, and fires a plasma weapon while docked in the ship. This causes a bunch of damage and casualties inside of the ship--priceless navigation equipment is destroyed, and whole groups of workers are deemed to be necessary sacrifices in order to stop the spread of plasma. Before they even reach the Halo Scar, the Speranza is already gravely wounded, which sets the tone that anything can be hurt, and the fleet hasn't yet accomplished anything they've set out to do. 


The most powerful characters also tend to be isolated or overwhelmed in battle. This one's pretty simple. The Reclusiarch of the Black Templars might best any human in hand-to-hand combat, but he's no match for a horde of mechanically-augmented orks or a lava-bodied demon-god from another dimension...


...And that's the third way to up the stakes! Even your superpowerful protags can be wounded or die IF THEIR ENEMIES ARE EVEN MORE POWERFUL. No single human warrior can reasonably expect to beat a literal fire god, and the wisdom of a few-thousand-year-old archmagos is nothing compared to a four-thousand-year-old sentient AI that's absorbed the brains & intelligences of countless other archmagi. Sure, this makes the fights a little wacky, but in a fun way that manages to keep the narrative "realistic" amidst an incredibly unrealistic setting. Because the most powerful characters are faced with obstacles that constantly overwhelm and one-up them, they seem more like people instead of the cardboard cutouts that litter the ground of SFF.


Ending note: the setting also functions as "superpowerful enemy," as all of the characters must stay inside their ships or die, and the terrain of the Halo Scar just ups the ante.


One More Thing

Okay I lied--I have a little bit more. I've been thinking a lot about resource management. It's a game mechanic we all know and love, but limited or depleting resources are a great way to create tension in fiction. The setting already implies a little bit of this, because everyone's in metal boxes hurtling through the instakill environment of outer space and are limited to the supplies of water/oxygen that fits on board. Once the setting becomes damaged (plasma cannon in the Speranza) or restricted (communications cut off as the party boarded Galatea's station / exits cut off by servitors) the finitude of resources becomes even more glaring. If "resource" is interpreted super loosely (even looser than I have already! Up those stakes!), it can also be adjacent to my conversation about stakes--the death of Reclusiarch Kul Gilad, for example, costs the fleet a skilled warrior and the Templars their leader. 


Anyway, I don't think there was a lot of "resource management" (as it's strictly defined) in the novel, but I think it can be kind of a useful concept, either by itself, or interpreted somewhat more abstractly when you're thinking about how to add tension to a piece.  




fayer: (Default)
The Goblin Emperor is one of my favorite sff books and also written by Monette, but under a pen name. I'd seen some weird things about 
Mélusine in reviews I'd read a while back, but a few months ago I just went "fuck it" and decided to get the first book.

I now have a problem. For the first 2 books, the parts that are good are really good, but the parts that are bad are awful. We'll get to the third book in a bit. Also this post will contain mild spoilers, but I'll try to be vague.

Let's start with the good things. The books have 2 main characters: Felix and Mildmay, and are told from their first-person POVs in alternating chapters. Felix is a gay wizard, and Mildmay is a  thief. I love both of them. I think their characters are really well-developed, and I'm attached to them and feel affection towards them and other characters in a way that is rare for published literature to make me feel. One of them also goes through a significant amount of trauma, which was depicted in a realistic way that resonated with me. Some parts made me even tear up a little on the train when I was reading them. Narrative depictions of trauma can be really hard to do, and authors tend to either 1) cringe away from writing the really bad shit and hurry to the recovery process, which can end up making the trauma feel like a plot mechanic for having only good things happen to your character,* or 2) not take the trauma seriously, which makes the portrayal come off as trite and offensive.

I also loved the worldbuilding. A lot of terms get thrown at you which aren't fully or immediately explained, and you have to learn things as you read, which makes the world feel really expansive and grounded in a way that worlds with immediately-explained phenomena don't feel to me. This is an aspect of The Goblin Emperor that I also loved. The world feels huge, and there's tantalizing tidbits of magic or history dropped into conversation that make me go "ooh, I hope I hear about this more in the future!" This really ramps up in the second book, when we're treated to a view of the world beyond the city of Melusine, and the stuff about labyrinths and thaumaturgical architecture starts to be discussed more fully.

Okay. Onto the parts I didn't like as much. This is more spoilery because I hckave to mention some specific things
[Rape/ Incest TW] These are both in the book. Felix gets raped in the very beginning of the first book by his abusive wizard mentor as part of a magical ritual. I think it was dealt with decently but just fair warning, this is the level of abuse he receives. Then Felix has conflicting ~feelings~ towards Mildmay after they get together, because if being gay isn't taboo in your sf world, you just HAVE to make the love forbidden another way, and unfortunately a lot of spec-fic authors seem to think incest is the way to solving this. That's fucked up. It occurs a little bit in the first book, and is a pretty big thread in the 2nd book, and I don't think there's any need for it. As of where I am in the series now, he hasn't acted on it, but I think it was a completely uncessary inclusion and also kinda homophobic. Which, homophobia wrt: depiction of Felix is part of what makes me uncomfortable with the series as a whole. For the entire first book, he is helpless and abused by the people around him and at an institutional level. The only other gay character is the evil one who contributed to most of the abuse. Then, in the second book, he starts regaining his power (""social clout"") and is a huge asshole. In the third book, he becomes abusive towards some people and worries he is turning into his abuser. I am deeply unsure about this arc, and I think his "recovery" is very bleak and unfair, since (so far) he hasn't really become "recovered," only more entrenched in patterns of abuse that dominate his life. I really don't know how to feel about this. I of course am not just interested in "happy" depictions of gay people, and tend to prefer the messy and problematic shit, but like. He can't catch a break. Maybe if there were more gay characters besides him and his ex-lovers/ex-abusers, it'd make me feel better because it'd be less of a tokenizing thing? Idk. I'm also disappointed in the contrasting aspects of Felix and Mildmay's romantic relationships that they each start at the end of book 2. Mildmay gets some real romance. He and his GF really seem to care for each other. Felix's thought process is basically like "I see this dude, he has a crush on me, he's available, I might as well use my charisma to get some sexual release!" I don't think I need to explain how this can be interpreted as homophobic. **

I also am only about halfway through the third book as I write this because it's a lot weaker than the first two. It rambles around with a number of loose threads that I'm not super interested in, and the worldbuilding's become tedious. While initially not having a lot of things explained worked to catch my interest, it's now doing the opposite, because there's too many aspects of the world that are only a little bit fleshed out, and since I'm not learning much more, and am still unclear on some basic ways the world functions, I'm becoming suspicious that there isn't really all that much thought put into what's behind it. If there was, I suspect I'd have heard more by now. There's only 1.5 books left in the series, after all, so there's not much time for it! 

Anyway, I'm pretty sure I'll finish the series....eventually. Right now I'm occupied with The Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu, which is proving to be just as good as everybody said it was.

----------
*Example: Joust by Mercedes Lackey. The MC is horribly mistreated for the first chapter, which, in Lackey's mind, allows her to not give him any serious obstacles to overcome throughout the rest of the book.
**I'd just like to reiterate that I'm all for literature exploring gays in messy/problematic/unhealthy relationships. It's one of my favorite things to write, personally. I guess what makes me suspicious of stuff like this is I'm not sure of its point in being included in this book. In explicitly "LGBT fiction" books, I'm cool with these portrayals because the author is explicitly "part of us", writing "to" and "for" us. I'm not sure how much of the Labyrinths series is "straight gaze" and how much "speaks from experience," which portrayals are intentional and which are thoughtless. Having articulated this, I'm not sure if it's a valid source of critique. Did Roland Barthes die for this? 

Profile

fayer: (Default)
Wander

January 2021

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10 111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Oct. 12th, 2026 09:36 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios